The Pond That Never Ends is the fifth episode of The Greatest Imaginations in the History of Philosophy, a hand-drawn-style 2D short released in English and Chinese. It picks up where Episode 3 left off: Peter Singer’s drowning child, and the conclusion that our everyday spending is morally on a par with walking past a child in a pond.1

Singer’s case persuades because it is a single rescue at a trivial cost, and almost no one would refuse. From that intuition Singer draws a general principle: if we can prevent something very bad without sacrificing anything of comparable moral importance, we ought to do it. Travis Timmerman’s 2015 paper accepts the intuition but questions the step to the principle.2

Timmerman asks us to meet Lisa. Hackers are draining two hundred dollars from her bank account every five minutes until she reaches the bank to stop them. Between her and the bank lie hundreds of shallow ponds, each with a drowning child. Every rescue costs her five more minutes, and so another two hundred dollars. The next day it all happens again, every day, for the rest of her life.

Each rescue, taken on its own, costs Lisa very little, so Singer’s principle tells her to keep saving until nearly everything she owns is gone and never to stop for anything else. Yet most of us judge that she does nothing wrong if, once in eighty years, she lets a child drown so she can go to the theater. A universal principle falls to a single counterexample: if that judgement is right, sometimes there is nothing wrong with letting a child drown, and the principle is false. Timmerman’s quieter point is that Singer’s single pond was never the right model of our world. Ours is Lisa’s: the need never runs out, and the costs add up.

The argument does not license indifference. Timmerman does not say we owe nothing; he leaves the amount open, suggesting only that it matches what Lisa would owe in her endless field. Philosophers still disagree about whether our intuition about Lisa can be trusted, and about what should replace Singer’s principle if it fails. The film ends where the debate does: more than nothing, but everything?

Endnotes

  1. Singer, Peter. “Famine, Affluence, and Morality.” Philosophy & Public Affairs, vol. 1, no. 3, 1972, pp. 229–243. back
  2. Timmerman, Travis. “Sometimes There Is Nothing Wrong with Letting a Child Drown.” Analysis, vol. 75, no. 2, 2015, pp. 204–212. back